The peril of grammar nit-picking

I’m following the BBC’s excellent Olympic live-update page, which combines a video stream with irreverent text updates from a relay team of BBC staffers. One of the things that keeps cropping up is viewers complaining about the use of the word ‘medal’ as a verb.

Look, folks: if you’re going to get all nit-picky about grammar, make sure you check your facts. The OED isn’t free, of course, and the edition I have to hand is one of the crappy one. But pick any other online dictionary and you’ll find that ‘medal’ can be a verb. Here’s the American Heritage Dictionary on my Mac, for example:

medal | ˈmedl |
noun
a metal disk with an inscription or design, made to commemorate an event or awarded as a distinction to someone such as a soldier, athlete, or scholar.

verb ( medaled | ˈmɛdld |, medaling | ˈmɛdlɪŋ |; also chiefly Brit. medalled, medalling) [ intrans. ]
earn a medal, esp. in an athletic contest : Norwegian athletes medaled in 12 of the 14 events

Yes, I was surprised too. But it’s not bad English just because we haven’t had the chance to use it very often.

1 Comment

Chambers gives ‘vt to decorate with a medal’ but not this Olympic vi. Moreover, casting aspersions freely, I should be pleased to see the evidence that the particular example in the American Heritage Dictionary (a name which might protest too much) is quoted from genuine usage. That said, verbing nouns is a practice centuries old. Latter-day hackles rise, I suspect, largely because of its prevalence in the dialect of modern management. Grammatical nitpicking is, as you rightly observe, wide of the mark. Wincing may yet be appropriate.

Leave a comment

About Jonathan

Lapsed: physicist and television producer. Now: media consultant/freelance film-maker, trying to reignite public-service children's media, particularly around science and engineering.

Categories

Recent Entries

  • Internet Watch Foundation filtering

    Lots of talk on Twitter today about [this](http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/UK_ISPs_erect_%27Great_Firewall_of_Britain%27_to_censor_Wikipedia): six major UK ISPs (including mine, the previously-rather lovely [Be](https://www.bethere.co.uk/)/O2, also Orange, Virgin, Demon, EasyNet, PlusNet and...

  • Building buzz without a budget

    Here's an excellent, [short presentation from the Nature Conservancy](http://www.slideshare.net/jcolman/building-buzz-without-a-budget-presentation?nocache=5510&type=powerpoint), outlining their use of Digg to drive traffic to a new website they were promoting. I...

  • The supercomputer in your web browser

    Computational Fluid Dynamics... [in Flash](http://www.joecutting.com/windTunnel.php). This is plain *wrong*, I tell you....

  • Things to know about the Panasonic HMC150/1

    I finally succumbed, and bought a proper camera. A video camera, none of your stills nonsense, nor yet a [stills camera masquerading as a video...

  • Alexandria Railway Station is in Dalaman, Turkey.

    Quoth [Wikipedia](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalaman): > In 1906, Alexandria train station was built by mistake in Dalaman. ... In 1905 the then Khedive of Egypt Abbas Hilmi Pasha...

Close